Artist CDs
All the following titles are the original recordings / hit versions you remember

Paul Anka (from ABC master tapes) (Greatest Early Hits)
Paul Anka - The Story Of (Volume 1)
Paul Anka - The Story Of (Volume 2)
Paul Anka - Italiano (Greatest Early Hits in Italian)

Compilation CDs
All the following titles are the original recordings / hit versions you remember
These CDs include various artists

Rock Around the World
Hey! Look What I Found - Volume 1
Juke Box Hits - 1957 Volume 1
Catch a Falling Star - Volume 1
Catch a Falling Star - Volume 2

45 RPM Records
All the following titles are brand new 45s and are the original recordings / hit versions you remember. 

Click here for listing of Paul Anka 45s available